Buying Wordfast: Trados compatible? 论题张贴者: Luis Quirindongo
|
Luis Quirindongo 波多黎各 Local time: 02:55 正式会员 (自2014) English英语译成Spanish西班牙语 + ...
Hello to everyone. I\'m working for an agency that uses Trados and they want me to buy it, but I simply don\'t have the cash right now. They do not seem interested in all the bells and whistles, they only want to be able to send me a Trados file and receive the translation as a Trados file. I\'m considering Wordfast as an alternative since it\'s makers say it\'s compatible with Trados, but the price is so much less that I\'m wondering if this is too good to be true. So here\'s what I... See more Hello to everyone. I\'m working for an agency that uses Trados and they want me to buy it, but I simply don\'t have the cash right now. They do not seem interested in all the bells and whistles, they only want to be able to send me a Trados file and receive the translation as a Trados file. I\'m considering Wordfast as an alternative since it\'s makers say it\'s compatible with Trados, but the price is so much less that I\'m wondering if this is too good to be true. So here\'s what I\'d like to know: Is Wordfast REALLY compatible with Trados? Would I have any problems receiving and editing a Trados file? Would my agency (which only uses Trados) have any problems processing a file translated in WF? Any feature comparisons would also help.
Thanks a lot
Luis Q. ▲ Collapse | | |
|
Gerard de Noord 法国 Local time: 08:55 正式会员 (自2003) English英语译成Dutch荷兰语 + ... No problem if you receive and send uncleaned files | Sep 10, 2003 |
Hi, Read more on Sylver's site (http://www.your-translations.com/cat-wordfast_and_trados.htm). If the agency sends presegmented Trados-files (DOCs or RTFs) and expects uncleaned Trados-files back there's really nothing to worry about. Just download and try it. Regards, Gerard | | |
it worked perfectly | Sep 10, 2003 |
I have Wordfast and had some jobs with agencies that asked for Trados (of course they know I work with WF!) I have absolutely no problems and apparently nor have the agencies. They send the files (pre-segmented or not), sometimes HUGE TMs that WF imports beautifully, and then I send the cleaned or uncleaned files as requested. Trados is an excellent tool, but in my humble opinion, it isn't worth the investment for the freelancer when you have the option of Wordfast doing its j... See more I have Wordfast and had some jobs with agencies that asked for Trados (of course they know I work with WF!) I have absolutely no problems and apparently nor have the agencies. They send the files (pre-segmented or not), sometimes HUGE TMs that WF imports beautifully, and then I send the cleaned or uncleaned files as requested. Trados is an excellent tool, but in my humble opinion, it isn't worth the investment for the freelancer when you have the option of Wordfast doing its job at a fraction of the price. Good luck with your decision! Grace. ▲ Collapse | |
|
|
Sonja Tomaskovic (X) 德国 Local time: 08:55 English英语译成German德语 + ... Virtually yes | Sep 11, 2003 |
There are always some people out there who claim that WF is not 100% compatible with Trados. When working with WF, however, you won't see any of these differences or non-compatibility. I have been working with WF for more than 2 years now and have never had any problems with Trados files from clients, nor have my client had any problems with the uncleaned files/TMs I provided. | | |
ncfialho (X) Local time: 07:55 German德语译成Portuguese葡萄牙语 + ... NO ttx files | Sep 11, 2003 |
Hello, if there hast been big change in Wordfast it is definitely not able to deal with ttx files. I do a lot of work in Tag Editor (Trados) with ttx files and specila definitions for that files (dtd files) and I couldnt do this kind of thing in Wordfast So it depends on the kind of files they want you to translate Natália | | |
Gerard de Noord 法国 Local time: 08:55 正式会员 (自2003) English英语译成Dutch荷兰语 + ... OT TTX files in Wordfast | Sep 11, 2003 |
Natália Fialho wrote: Hello, if there hast been big change in Wordfast it is definitely not able to deal with ttx files. I do a lot of work in Tag Editor (Trados) with ttx files and specila definitions for that files (dtd files) and I couldnt do this kind of thing in Wordfast So it depends on the kind of files they want you to translate Natália Hi Natália, I know you like Wordfast so you should read this great post in a thread on the Wordfast group today. http://groups.yahoo.com/group/wordfast/message/28095 Regards, Gerard P.s. And, as I said before, working in tagged, presegmented Trados files is never a problem. | | |
Same experience as Gerard | Sep 12, 2003 |
One of my client's sends pre-segmented Trados files that I translate in Wordfast and send back uncleaned. No problems (that couldn't be attributed to my inexperience with Wordfast). They were even the ones who suggested I get Wordfast because almost all of their freelancers use that instead of Trados. I would be upfront about what you're using, though, in case some problems crop up. | |
|
|
Luis Quirindongo 波多黎各 Local time: 02:55 正式会员 (自2014) English英语译成Spanish西班牙语 + ... 主题发起人 Wordfast trial run (some help?) | Sep 12, 2003 |
Thanks to all for replying. I downloaded the trial version of Wordfast and it worked just fine with Trados files. I believe that the new version 4 supports TTX, but I will have to try it just to make sure. Anyway, I Did tell them I was using the program (tnk, Dania!) and it turns out that my agency had never heard of it. But they're doing a trial run now, so they want me to send some short files translated in Wordfast. I've gotten started and things are going fine, but I've never us... See more Thanks to all for replying. I downloaded the trial version of Wordfast and it worked just fine with Trados files. I believe that the new version 4 supports TTX, but I will have to try it just to make sure. Anyway, I Did tell them I was using the program (tnk, Dania!) and it turns out that my agency had never heard of it. But they're doing a trial run now, so they want me to send some short files translated in Wordfast. I've gotten started and things are going fine, but I've never used this program before and need some help. Particularly, I need to know about Trados extensions and how to link/export/import them to Wordfast (haven't worked with Trados either, so i need to know which is the memory, the glossary, etc.) Also, some tips for finishing up and sending would help. Thanks in advance, Luis ▲ Collapse | | |
sylver Local time: 14:55 English英语译成French法语
Luis José Quirindongo wrote: .... Anyway, I Did tell them I was using the program (tnk, Dania!) and it turns out that my agency had never heard of it. But they're doing a trial run now, so they want me to send some short files translated in Wordfast. I've gotten started and things are going fine, but I've never used this program before and need some help. Particularly, I need to know about Trados extensions and how to link/export/import them to Wordfast (haven't worked with Trados either, so i need to know which is the memory, the glossary, etc.) Also, some tips for finishing up and sending would help. Thanks in advance, Luis www.your-translations.com (in the links on the left side), you will find the answer to most of your questions, including a full article on how to use Wordfast to work on Trados projects. As far as file format goes, most trados files are simply word files specifically organized to hold both the source and the target together. You can read more about that in the page called "segmentation". Please let me know if you are having troubles along the way, as I am currently reviewing the web site, and all feedback is welcome indeed Cheers, Sylvain Cheers, Sylvain | | |